Nellie’s Place – Waldwick, NJ

by PizzaSnobo on March 14, 2011

9 Franklin Turnpike
Waldwick, NJ 07463

Nellie’s is your typical, run-down jersey pizza tavern serving thin crust pizza. There is a bar section and separate dinning room featuring a salad bar. We can’t remember the last time we saw a salad bar aside from the corner bodega. On a Saturday afternoon, it is frequented by families and also the local senior citizen community.

During this review, we tried the margarita ($15.95) which at Nellie’s includes sliced tomatoes in addition to the sauce: tomato overload! We liked the sauce but the tomato topping is too much. The fresh mozzarella is good but a bit too mild. The thin crust is great and perhaps even better than Kinchley’s. For a thin crust it has a nice chewiness to it.

Nellie’s gives a new meaning to the “Jersey tomato.” Next time we are going with just their regular pie. 

Department of Health Restaurant Grade Guideline

Leave a Comment


Previous post:

Next post: