Big Nick’s Burger & Pizza Joint – Multiple Locations, NYC

by PizzaSnobo on July 26, 2011

2175 Broadway / New York, NY 10024
(212) 362-9238 /

70 West 71st St. / New York, NY 10023
(212) 799-4444 /

There are two Big Nick’s on the Upper West Side. Both are known for large slices, greasy burgers and late night diner food. It’s a standby for most folks who live nearby, especially when it is time for delivery.

Big Nick’s is more of a restaurant than a pizzeria, so when you order they’ll bring the slices to you ($2.70). The crust is mostly devoid of flavor and can be so dry and crunchy that it snaps off when you fold it. The cheese is decent pizzeria mozzarella but nothing more. The sauce is also remarkably average, with a heavy dose of oregano.

The pizza here is nothing to write home about, especially when you feel a need to leave a tip for something so standard. But Big Nick’s has a big menu and they deliver late into the night.

PizzaSnobo Pizza Restaurant Review Grading 3.5 slices

Department of Health Restaurant rating A

Leave a Comment


{ 1 trackback }

Previous post:

Next post: